Up to top level
AO11   AO12   Backgrounds   Calibration   Conference   Data   Docs   EPICMOS   EPICpn   Feedback   Gallery   Misc   OM   Pending   PhD_Theses   Publications   RGS   RadMonitor   SAS_Hardware   SAS_WS   SASv12.0   SASv12.0_Installation   SASv13.0   SASv13.0_Installation   SciSim   Simulators_other   Suggestions   Trash   Visibility   XMM-bouncing   XMM-news   XRPS   XSA   esas   incoming  

Logged in as guest

Viewing SASv12.0/50728
Full headers

From: fabio.vito@unibo.it
Subject: specgroup attribute error
Compose reply
Move To:
3 replies: 1 2 3
2 followups: 1 2

Private message: yes  no

Notes:

Notification:


Date: Thu, 16 Aug 2012 14:09:24 GMT
From: fabio.vito@unibo.it
To: xmmhelp@sciops.esa.int
Cc: fabio.vito@unibo.it
Subject: specgroup attribute error
Full_Name: Fabio Vito
Submission from: (NULL) (137.204.47.97)


I get this error running specgroup (sas v12.0.0):

specgroup spectrumset=infile.pha backgndset=infile_bg.pha minSN=3.0
rmfset=infile.rmf arfset=infile.arf groupedset=outfile.pha setbad=no

** specgroup: error (attributableNotFound), Could not find attribute with
qualified name infile.pha%INSTRUME in attributable set infile.pha

I thought this error should be resolved by setbad=no but this seems not the
case.
What is wrong with the command I have typed?

Fabio Vito


Reply 1

Resend
From: Pedro M. Rodriguez Pascual <xmmhelp@sciops.esa.int>
To: fabio.vito@unibo.it
Subject: Re: specgroup attribute error (PR#50728)
Date: Thu Aug 16 14:20:59 2012
Hi,

specgroup needs to know which XMM instrument is the origin of the input data and
looks for it in the INSTRUME keyword in the header of the input spectrum file.
From the error description,  it seems to complain because such keyword is
missing.

Pedro



Followup 1

Compose reply
Date: Thu, 16 Aug 2012 16:25:57 +0200
From: "fabio.vito" <fabio.vito@unibo.it>
To: "Pedro M. Rodriguez Pascual" <xmmhelp@sciops.esa.int>
Subject: Re: specgroup attribute error (PR#50728)
Thank you Pedro!
However, the INSTRUMENT keyword seems ok:
0008 INSTRUME             EPN String       instrument/detector name

Moreover, the same command works for the same files on another computer 
(sas v11.0.0)..
Fabio


Il 16/08/2012 16:20, Pedro M. Rodriguez Pascual ha scritto:
> Hi,
>
> specgroup needs to know which XMM instrument is the origin of the input
data and
> looks for it in the INSTRUME keyword in the header of the input spectrum
file.
>  From the error description,  it seems to complain because such keyword is
> missing.
>
> Pedro
>
>
>
> This message and any attachments are intended for the use of the addressee
or addressees only. The unauthorised disclosure, use, dissemination or copying
(either in whole or in part) of its content is not permitted. If you received
this message in error, please notify the sender and delete it from your system.
Emails can be altered and their integrity cannot be guaranteed by the sender.
>
> Please consider the environment before printing this email.
>



Reply 2

Resend
From: Pedro M. Rodriguez Pascual <xmmhelp@sciops.esa.int>
To: fabio.vito@unibo.it
Subject: Re: specgroup attribute error (PR#50728)
Date: Thu Aug 16 14:29:29 2012
May we get the files infile.pha, infile_bg.pha, infile.rmf and infile.arf in
order to debug the error?

Pedro



Followup 2

Compose reply
Date: Thu, 16 Aug 2012 16:50:20 +0200
From: "fabio.vito" <fabio.vito@unibo.it>
To: "Pedro M. Rodriguez Pascual" <xmmhelp@sciops.esa.int>
Subject: Re: specgroup attribute error (PR#50728)
--------------090601030906010806040409
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="ISO-8859-15"; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

infile.pha is actually a sum of individual spectra
Fabio


--------------090601030906010806040409
Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="files.tar.gz"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="files.tar.gz"
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Message of length 2529531 truncated


Reply 3

Resend
From: Pedro M. Rodriguez Pascual <xmmhelp@sciops.esa.int>
To: fabio.vito@unibo.it
Subject: Re: specgroup attribute error (PR#50728)
Date: Thu Aug 16 15:09:41 2012
Hi,

specgroup is designed to work on a spectrum from a single exposure (camera,
mode, filter). Then, it will complain about the following missing keywords in
the main header of infile.pha (it does not matter if they are present in first
extension):

INSTRUME
DATE-OBS
RA_PNT
DEC_PNT
PA_PNT
TELESCOP
DATAMODE
FILTER

so, try to fill in these keywords with some meaningful values to make specgroup
to work. But I do not know if the success is guaranteed when the input spectrum
is in fact the sum of several spectra.

Pedro

Up to top level
AO11   AO12   Backgrounds   Calibration   Conference   Data   Docs   EPICMOS   EPICpn   Feedback   Gallery   Misc   OM   Pending   PhD_Theses   Publications   RGS   RadMonitor   SAS_Hardware   SAS_WS   SASv12.0   SASv12.0_Installation   SASv13.0   SASv13.0_Installation   SciSim   Simulators_other   Suggestions   Trash   Visibility   XMM-bouncing   XMM-news   XRPS   XSA   esas   incoming  

Logged in as guest


Please make your (short) question the subject of your request!


Web interface using JitterBug ... back to the XMM home page