Up to top level
AO15   AO16   AO17   AO18   AO19   Backgrounds   Calibration   Conference   Data   Docs   EPICMOS   EPICpn   Feedback   Gallery   Misc   OM   Pending   PhD_Theses   Publications   RGS   RadMonitor   SAS_Hardware   SAS_WS   SASv16.0   SASv16.0_Installation   SASv16.1   SASv16.1_Installation   SASv17.0   SASv17.0_Installation   SASv18.0   SASv18.0_Installation   SciSim   Simulators_other   Suggestions   Trash   Visibility   XMM-bouncing   XMM-news   XRPS   XSA   esas   incoming  

Logged in as guest

Viewing Misc/10233
Full headers

From: "Angel" <angelchase91@hotmail.com>
Subject: the uncertainty principle is untenable
Compose reply
Download message
Move To:
0 replies:
0 followups:

Private message: yes  no

Notes:

Notification:


From: "Angel" <angelchase91@hotmail.com>
Subject: the uncertainty principle is untenable
To: xmmhelp@xmm.vilspa.esa.es
Date: Tue, 24 Feb 2004 11:35:28 +0800
Please reply to hdgbyi@public.guangzhou.gd.cn .
Thank you ! 
 

THE UNCERTAINTY PRINCIPLE IS UNTENABLE

 

By re-analysing Heisenberg's Gamma-Ray Microscope experiment and the ideal
experiment from which the uncertainty principle is derived, it is actually found
that the uncertainty principle can not be obtained from them. It is therefore
found to be untenable. 

Key words: 
uncertainty principle; Heisenberg's Gamma-Ray Microscope Experiment; ideal
experiment 

Ideal Experiment 1

                 Heisenberg's Gamma-Ray Microscope Experiment


A free electron sits directly beneath the center of the microscope's lens
(please see AIP page http://www.aip.org/history/heisenberg/p08b.htm or diagram
below) . The circular lens forms a cone of angle 2A from the electron. The
electron is then illuminated from the left by gamma rays--high energy light
which has the shortest wavelength. These yield the highest resolution, for
according to a principle of wave optics, the microscope can resolve (that is,
"see" or distinguish) objects to a size of dx, which is related to and to the
wavelength L of the gamma ray, by the expression: 

dx = L/(2sinA) (1) 

However, in quantum mechanics, where a light wave can act like a particle, a
gamma ray striking an electron gives it a kick. At the moment the light is
diffracted by the electron into the microscope lens, the electron is thrust to
the right. To be observed by the microscope, the gamma ray must be scattered
into any angle within the cone of angle 2A. In quantum mechanics, the gamma ray
carries momentum as if it were a particle. The total momentum p is related to
the wavelength by the formula, 

p = h / L, where h is Planck's constant. (2) 

In the extreme case of diffraction of the gamma ray to the right edge of the
lens, the total momentum would be the sum of the electron's momentum P'x in the
x direction and the gamma ray's momentum in the x direction: 

P' x + (h sinA) / L', where L' is the wavelength of the deflected gamma ray. 

In the other extreme, the observed gamma ray recoils backward, just hitting the
left edge of the lens. In this case, the total momentum in the x direction is: 

P''x - (h sinA) / L''. 

The final x momentum in each case must equal the initial x momentum, since
momentum is conserved. Therefore, the final x momenta are equal to each other: 

P'x + (h sinA) / L' = P''x - (h sinA) / L'' (3) 

If A is small, then the wavelengths are approximately the same, 

L' ~ L" ~ L. So we have 

P''x - P'x = dPx ~ 2h sinA / L (4) 

Since dx = L/(2 sinA), we obtain a reciprocal relationship between the minimum
uncertainty in the measured position, dx, of the electron along the x axis and
the uncertainty in its momentum, dPx, in the x direction: 

dPx ~ h / dx or dPx dx ~ h. (5) 

For more than minimum uncertainty, the "greater than" sign may added. 

Except for the factor of 4pi and an equal sign, this is Heisenberg's uncertainty
relation for the simultaneous measurement of the position and momentum of an
object. 

Re-analysis

To be seen by the microscope, the gamma ray must be scattered into any angle
within the cone of angle 2A. 

The microscope can resolve (that is, "see" or distinguish) objects to a size of
dx, which is related to and to the wavelength L of the gamma ray, by the
expression: 

dx = L/(2sinA) (1) 

This is the resolving limit of the microscope and it is the uncertain quantity
of the object's position. 

The microscope can not see the object whose size is smaller than its resolving
limit, dx. Therefore, to be seen by the microscope, the size of the electron
must be larger than or equal to the resolving limit. 

But if the size of the electron is larger than or equal to the resolving limit
dx, the electron will not be in the range dx. Therefore, dx can not be deemed to
be the uncertain quantity of the electron's position which can be seen by the
microscope, but deemed to be the uncertain quantity of the electron's position
which can not be seen by the microscope. To repeat, dx is uncertainty in the
electron's position which can not be seen by the microscope. 

To be seen by the microscope, the gamma ray must be scattered into any angle
within the cone of angle 2A, so we can measure the momentum of the electron. 

dPx is the uncertainty in the electron's momentum which can be seen by
microscope. 

What relates to dx is the electron where the size is smaller than the resolving
limit. When the electron is in the range dx, it can not be seen by the
microscope, so its position is uncertain. 

What relates to dPx is the electron where the size is larger than or equal to
the resolving limit .The electron is not in the range dx, so it can be seen by
the microscope and its position is certain. 

Therefore, the electron which relates to dx and dPx respectively is not the
same. What we can see is the electron where the size is larger than or equal to
the resolving limit dx and has a certain position, dx = 0. 

Quantum mechanics does not rely on the size 

Message of length 9219 truncated
Up to top level
AO15   AO16   AO17   AO18   AO19   Backgrounds   Calibration   Conference   Data   Docs   EPICMOS   EPICpn   Feedback   Gallery   Misc   OM   Pending   PhD_Theses   Publications   RGS   RadMonitor   SAS_Hardware   SAS_WS   SASv16.0   SASv16.0_Installation   SASv16.1   SASv16.1_Installation   SASv17.0   SASv17.0_Installation   SASv18.0   SASv18.0_Installation   SciSim   Simulators_other   Suggestions   Trash   Visibility   XMM-bouncing   XMM-news   XRPS   XSA   esas   incoming  

Logged in as guest


Please make your (short) question the subject of your request!


Web interface using JitterBug ... back to the XMM home page